Chandigarh July 4(Bharatsandesh news) – The Punjab Chief Minister Mr. Parkash Singh Badal today warned the Government of India of “serious political and law and order implications” in case the Center went ahead with its move to renew industrial concessions to J&K, HP and Uttrakhand without the same concessions being given to “ far more deserving sensitive border state of Punjab.”
The Chief Minister sought the direct intervention of the Prime Minister in this matter to “save the state from further ruin and chaos by treating us at par with the neighboring states while granting such industrial or other economic incentives.”
In a letter to the Prime Minister, Mr Badal said that he earlier package of concessions given to these states had played havoc with the economy of our state and “a repetition of the ruinous decision and the consequent disenchantment and disillusionment it will set off in the youth of our state can have serious political and law and order implications.”
Protesting that any “ruinous” decision to this effect would prove to be the proverbial last straw to break our back, Mr Badal that the Punjabis who had braved several daunting odds in the past would find “it impossible to battle the discrimination of their own national government against them.”
The Chief Minister traced the history of the various natural, historical and strategic challenges that the Punjabis had battled in the interest of nation. “The state battled the travails of partition and heroically not only re-built the state but also emerged as the granary and sword-arm of the nation. Our contributions in both fields have no parallels in the country. In addition, Punjabis braved the ravages caused by three wars with a hostile neighbor and have never been compensated for the huge costs they had to suffer in doing so.
Mr Badal also referred to the “long years of militancy, which severely halted its progress and caused immense damage to its economy, development and progress, especially in the field of industry. The flight of capital from Punjab during the militancy years has no parallels in national history.”
But, said the Chief Minister, “Just as Punjabis were engaged heroically in rebuilding the state and its economy, we were dealt a deadly blow by the denial of industrial concessions granted to our neighboring states, making business and industry here extremely non-competitive.”
Mr. Badal said that Punjab is not against incentives of concessions being given to any other state “so long as Punjab, which has a far greater claim on such concessions, is not discriminated against. This policy has already ruined industry and overall growth of our State. Flight of capital in business and industry, as a direct consequence of this policy, has severely hit the employment scenario for our youth. These factors have had a crippling impact on the State’s economy.”
The Chief Minister said another reason why it is illogical to deny Punjab the concessions given to other states. “The only reason for extending concessions to the states mentioned above is that they are strategically disadvantaged in terms of location. That argument applies far more forcefully to the border state of Punjab. “There are natural disadvantages which the state of Punjab has had to bear for being a land-locked border state, with a long and active border with a hostile neighbor, and practically no access to international markets. The people of the state fought these disadvantages manfully and heroically. But they find it impossible to battle the discrimination of their own national government against them.”
The Chief Minister’s letter comes in the wake of “a recent Notification issued by the Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion, Ministry of Commerce & Industry, Government of India, extending the Special Package of Industrial Incentives to the State of Jammu & Kashmir up to June 14, 2017. Further, the Government of India is contemplating extension of tax concessions to the other two of States also as were granted in the year 2002-03,” Mr. Badal noted in his letter to the PM.
TEXT OF THE LETTER
I would like to draw your kind attention to my earlier DO letter dated 09.02.2010 requesting you for grant of Special Package of incentives for industrial units in Punjab on the pattern of those granted to Jammu & Kashmir, Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand.
In this connection, your kind attention is also invited to the recent Notification issued by the Department of Industrial Policy & Promotion, Ministry of Commerce & Industry, Government of India vide their letter No. 1(10)/2012-SPS dated 11.06.2013, extending the Special Package of Industrial Incentives to the State of Jammu & Kashmir up to 14.06.2017.
It is understood that Government of India is contemplating extension of tax concessions to the other two of the aforementioned States also as were granted in the year 2002-03.
This has sent alarm signals in business and industry in Punjab, already reeling under the adverse impact of a series of circumstances and decisions of the Government of India.
I hardly need to reiterate the extremely sensitive and special status that the state of Punjab holds. No one knows it better than you how the people of the state battled the travails of partition and heroically not only re-built the state but also emerged as the granary and sword-arm of the nation. Our contributions in both fields have no parallels in the country, as your good self is well aware.
In addition, Punjabis braved the ravages caused by three wars with a hostile neighbor and have never been compensated for the huge costs they had to suffer in doing so.
The state also suffered long years of militancy, which severely halted its progress and caused immense damage to its economy, development and progress, especially in the field of industry. The flight of capital from Punjab during the militancy years has no parallels in national history.
But just as Punjabis were engaged heroically in rebuilding the state and its economy, we were dealt a deadly blow by the denial of industrial concessions granted to our neighboring states, making business and industry here extremely uncompetitive. We have repeatedly said that we are not against incentives of concessions being given to any other state so long as Punjab, which has a far greater claim on such concessions, is not discriminated against. This policy has already ruined industry and overall growth of our State. Flight of capital in business and industry, as a direct consequence of this policy, has severely hit the employment scenario for our youth. These factors have had a crippling impact on the State’s economy .
All this is in addition to the natural disadvantages which the state of Punjab has had to bear for being a land-locked border state, with a long and active border with a hostile neighbor, and practically no access to international markets. The people of the state fought these disadvantages manfully and heroically. But they find it impossible to battle the discrimination of their own national government against them.
I wish to emphasize here that the only reason for extending concessions to the states mentioned above is that they are strategically disadvantaged in terms of location. That argument applies far more forcefully to the border state of Punjab.
As representative of a suffering and beleaguered people, I most earnestly and humbly request you to consider our earlier request for grant of the same concessions to us that were and/or are proposed to be granted to other states in our neighborhood.
Concessions already granted to our neighbouring states and their denial to us in 2002 have ruined Punjab’s economy and are at the root of all the problems we face on the economic front.
A new decision to the same effect will completely destroy our economy. It will be the proverbial last straw.
I deem it my national duty to apprise you that a repetition of the ruinous decision to grant such concessions to our neighbouring states and the consequent disenchantment and disillusionment it will set off in the youth of our state can have serious political and law and order implications.
I earnestly and humbly request you to intervene in the matter and save the state from further ruin and chaos by treating us at par with the neighboring states while granting such industrial or other economic incentives.
While doing so, a Special Package for the border areas of the State may separately be granted.
Yours sincerely,
Sd/-
(Parkash Singh Badal)
Dr. Manmohan Singh,
Prime Minister of India,
New Delhi.
